Table Of Contents
Finding a reliable roofing contractor in Yorkville, IL takes more than a quick online search. Roofs are a significant investment, and the contractor you choose affects everything from material quality and installation standards to warranty coverage and how smoothly an insurance claim gets handled. To build this list, we evaluated companies on verifiable credentials (such as GAF Master Elite status and BBB accreditation), customer review volume and consistency, service area coverage relative to Yorkville, and transparency around warranties and limitations. Every entry includes an honest look at where each contractor excels and where they may fall short.
| Company | Best For | Starting Price | Rating |
| Advanced Roofing Inc. | Best for comprehensive, long-term local service | On request | 4.8 (192 Google) |
| A.R. Roofing, Siding & Gutters | Best for insurance claim assistance | On request | 4.8 (37 Google) |
| SR&R Roofing | Best for commercial & industrial roofing projects | On request | N/A |
| Mueller Roofing Inc. | Best for 24-hr emergency service | On request | 4.4 (206 Google) |
| Randall and Son Roofing | Best for verified high-volume reviews | On request | 5.0 (733+ Google) |
| Able-Warnecke Roofing | Best for small repairs | On request | 5.0 (17 Google) |
| A&D Exteriors | Best for premium exterior projects | On request | 5.0 (179+ Google) |
| Salazar Roofing & Construction | Best for insurance claim navigation | On request | 4.8 (40 Google) |
Location: 311 E Van Emmon St, Yorkville, IL 60560
Service Area: Naperville, Aurora, Yorkville, Plainfield, Oswego, St. Charles, and greater Chicagoland
Phone: (630) 553-2344
Rating: 4.8 stars / 192 Google reviews | 4.7 stars on HomeAdvisor
Pricing: On request; free consultations and detailed estimates available
Website: advancedroofing.biz
Founded in 1994, Advanced Roofing Inc. brings more than 30 years of roofing experience to Yorkville and the surrounding Chicagoland area. They handle everything from residential roof replacement and storm damage restoration to commercial roofing, siding, gutters, and windows. What puts them near the top of this list is the combination of a Yorkville address, GAF Master Elite status (awarded to fewer than 2% of roofing contractors nationwide, and a consistently high review score across nearly 200 Google reviews.
Location: 1308 Sunset Avenue, Yorkville, IL 60560
Service Area: Yorkville, Plano, Sugar Grove, Oswego, Montgomery, Plainfield, Aurora, Naperville, and surrounding areas
Phone: (630) 554-3317
Rating: 4.8 stars / 37 Google reviews | 5.0 stars on HomeAdvisor
Pricing: On request
Website: arroofingsidinggutters.com
A.R. Roofing, Siding & Gutters Inc. is another Yorkville-based contractor, which means shorter drive times and genuine familiarity with local weather patterns and code requirements. They work with leading material brands, including GAF, IKO, CertainTeed, and Velux, and hold BBB A+ Accreditation (since 2013). Reviewers consistently call out the owner's responsiveness and willingness to handle unexpected issues fairly, which matters a lot when a roof project uncovers hidden problems.
Location: Yorkville, IL 60560
Service Area: Yorkville, Chicagoland area, with a stated nationwide reach for commercial and industrial projects
Phone: 866-941-8855
Rating: N/A
Pricing: On request; free consultations with stated 24–48 hour estimate turnaround
Website: https://sr-roof.com/
SR&R Roofing has been serving the Chicagoland area from its Yorkville location since 1980, bringing more than four decades of experience to local property owners. The company offers a broad service mix that covers residential, commercial, and industrial roofing, along with metal roofs, high-end luxury systems like cedar shake and slate, HVAC services, and full insurance claim management. Their stated specialties include infrared roof leak detection, flat roof work, and 24-hour emergency leak service, with free estimates returned within 24-48 hours.
Location: 2827 Manhattan Rd, Joliet, IL 60433
Service Area: Joliet, New Lenox, Orland Park, Will, Grundy, and DuPage counties
Phone: (815) 726-0730
Rating: 4.4 stars / 206 Google reviews | 4.6 stars on Angi
Pricing: On request
Website: muellerroofing.com
Mueller Roofing Inc. has been operating since 1960, giving them over 60 years of residential and commercial roofing experience across the broader Will, Grundy, and DuPage county area. They are locally owned and operated, hold an Illinois License 104-016228, and carry BBB A+ Accreditation. Their differentiator is a 24-hour emergency roofing service, which is valuable when a storm causes sudden damage. Their 206 Google reviews give a meaningful sample size, though the 4.4-star score reflects some mixed experiences worth reviewing before committing.
Location: 815 E Main St, St. Charles, IL 60174
Service Area: Fox Valley area and West Suburbs (including Aurora and Batavia)
Phone: 847-695-4990
Rating: 5.0 stars / 733+ Google reviews | Strong ratings on Angi and Yelp
Pricing: On request
Website: rnsroofing.com
Founded in 1981, Randall and Son Roofing and Exteriors has built one of the largest verified review bases of any contractor on this list, with more than 733 Google reviews holding a 5.0-star average. Reviewers consistently praise clear communication, prompt follow-up, and an absence of high-pressure sales tactics. They hold the Shingle Master Premier CertainTeed designation and carry an A+ BBB rating. The main consideration for Yorkville homeowners: the company is based in St. Charles, and while they serve the Fox Valley and West Suburbs, Yorkville sits toward the outer edge of that footprint.
Location: 31W126 91st St, Naperville, IL 60564
Service Area: Naperville and west suburbs, including Yorkville, Aurora, Oswego, and Plainfield
Phone: 630-851-3004
Rating: 5.0 stars / 17 Google reviews | 4.7 stars on Angi
Pricing: On request; free estimates offered
Website: able-warnecke.com
Established in 1972, Able-Warnecke is a family-owned operation with more than 50 years in the business. Owner Ed Warnecke is personally involved in estimates and on-site work, which provides a level of hands-on oversight that larger companies often cannot match. They explicitly list Yorkville in their service area and are known for taking on small repair jobs that bigger contractors turn away. They hold an Illinois Roofing License 104.000464 and have been BBB Accredited since 1980 with an A+ rating.
Location: 50 S Main St, Suite 200-5, Naperville, IL 60540
Service Area: Naperville and western Chicago suburbs
Phone: (800) 557-1398
Rating: 5.0 stars / 166+ Google reviews | 4.9 stars on Angi (700 reviews)
Pricing: On request
Website: andexteriors.com
A&D Exteriors brings years of experience to residential exterior work across the Naperville area, with a reputation that is hard to argue with: 700 Angi reviews averaging 4.9 stars and an Angie's List Super Service Award every year since 2012. They are a BBB A+ Accredited business and offer a 12-year no-leak workmanship warranty. They also employ an in-house designer, which is useful for homeowners who want a cohesive look across roofing, siding, and windows. The question for Yorkville residents is whether the company actively services the area, as their recent projects page does not explicitly list Yorkville. Call to confirm before requesting an estimate.
Location: 3847 N Sawyer Ave, Chicago, IL 60618 (Illinois office)
Service Area: Oklahoma, Colorado, Florida, and Louisiana
Phone: 866-722-6558
Rating: 4.8 stars / 40 Google reviews (Chicago location)
Pricing: On request
Website: salazarroofing.com
Salazar Roofing & Construction has been family-owned since 1978 and holds multi-state licensing and BBB A+ Accreditation. For homeowners dealing with storm damage and a complicated insurance process, their focus on insurance claim handling and treating clients with a direct, non-upselling approach has earned strong reviews for their Chicago location. The key limitation for Yorkville homeowners to understand: their Illinois office is in Chicago, and their operations are spread across multiple states, which makes them the least geographically local option on this list.
None of the contractors on this list publishes pricing online, which is typical for roofing, since costs depend on roof size, pitch, material choice, and whether a tear-off is needed. As a general reference, asphalt shingle replacements for an average-sized home in the greater Chicago suburbs tend to range from $8,000 to $20,000 or more, but this figure can move significantly based on your specific project. Request at least three itemized estimates before deciding, and confirm what each quote includes in terms of material grade, warranty, and cleanup.
The most meaningful credential for asphalt shingle roofing is GAF Master Elite status, which requires ongoing training, proper licensing, and adequate insurance, and is held by fewer than 2% of roofing contractors. CertainTeed's ShingleMaster or Shingle Master Premier designation serves a similar purpose. BBB A+ Accreditation and state licensing (Illinois requires a roofing contractor license) are also important baseline checks. Several contractors on this list carry multiple credentials, which reduces risk when selecting a company.
Whether insurance covers your roof depends on the cause of damage and the terms of your specific policy. Storm damage from hail or wind is typically covered; gradual wear is generally not. Several contractors on this list actively assist with the insurance claim process, including A.R. Roofing, Mueller Roofing, and Salazar Roofing. Regardless of which company you hire, request a written scope of work before the adjuster visits so you have documentation to support your claim.
For a standard residential shingle replacement, most crews complete the work in one to three days, depending on roof size, complexity, and weather. Delays are more common when permits take longer to process or when a project uncovers structural damage that needs repair before the new roof goes on.
Yes, always. Roofing estimates can vary by thousands of dollars for the same scope of work, and the differences often reflect material quality, warranty terms, and what is included in cleanup and disposal rather than just labor cost. Getting three to four quotes gives you enough data to identify outliers in either direction, ask more targeted questions, and make a decision based on value rather than price alone.
For most Yorkville homeowners, starting with a locally based contractor will give you the fastest response times and the clearest accountability if something needs to be addressed after the project wraps up.
Advanced Roofing Inc. and A.R. Roofing are both Yorkville-based with strong credentials. Randall and Son is the right call if a large, verified review base is your primary trust signal.
Able-Warnecke is ideal if you need a small repair done right without being pushed toward a full replacement. As for commercial projects and industrial projects, you can rely on SR&R Roofing.
For projects where an insurance claim is the central challenge, A.R. Roofing, Mueller Roofing, and Salazar Roofing all bring specific experience in that area. Whatever you decide, request written estimates, confirm licensing and insurance, and ask for references from recent projects in the Yorkville area before signing.
